TakeoffYard
Home/Guides/Concrete bags vs ready-mix: where the break-even really is
Concrete & Masonry · 4 min read

Concrete bags vs ready-mix: where the break-even really is

Bags are convenient, but mixing more than a cubic yard or meter by hand gets expensive in time and quality. Here is how to decide.

On a small job the choice between bagged concrete and a ready-mix truck comes down to three things: volume, access and labor. Material price is only part of the answer. A pour that looks cheaper in bags can easily cost more once you count the hours, the mixer hire and the risk of a poor finish.

How much a bag actually makes

An 80 lb bag of concrete mix yields about 0.6 cu ft, so you need 45 of them for one cubic yard. A 60 lb bag yields about 0.45 cu ft (60 per yard), and a 40 lb bag 0.3 cu ft (90 per yard). That is roughly 1.8 tons of material to lift, tip, mix and place for every yard.

The real cost of bags

Add up the hidden costs of a bag pour:

  • Labor. A two-person crew with a mixer realistically places 1 to 1.5 yards an hour once you include fetching bags, loading, mixing, barrowing and placing. A small slab can easily take a full day for two people.
  • Consistency. Every batch varies a little in water content. On a large slab this shows as patchy color, uneven strength and cracking.
  • Cold joints. If one end of the slab starts to set before the other is finished, you get a weak plane right through it.
  • Handling and waste. Split bags, part bags left over, wet bags and wasted water all add up.
  • Equipment. Mixer hire, plus transport for a pallet or two of bags. A pallet often weighs over a ton, beyond what most pickups or vans can carry.

Rules of thumb

VolumeUsually best
Under ⅓ cu yd (post holes, small pads)Bags
⅓ to 1 cu ydBags with a mixer, or a small-load supplier
Over 1 cu ydReady-mix truck
Any volume with poor accessReady-mix with a line pump, or powered barrow hire

Short-load fees and minimums

Most US plants add a short-load fee for orders under 3–5 yards, either a charge per missing yard or a flat fee, and some add Saturday or after-hours charges too. Even with the fee, a truck often beats bags once you count labor, because a crew can place a small load in under an hour and spend the rest of the day finishing.

A quick comparison

Take a 2-yard patio. In bags that's 90 bags of 80 lb, plus mixer hire, and two people for most of a day. By truck it's 2 yards plus a short-load fee, and the pour takes about 30 minutes. Unless your labor is free, the truck usually wins. Use the slab calculator to get your volume, then compare your own bag price and labor rate against a phone quote from a local plant.

Site mixing from cement and aggregate

Mixing from Portland cement, sand and gravel is cheaper per yard than pre-mixed bags, but harder to keep consistent. About 5½ bags of 94 lb cement per yard, with roughly 0.65 tons of sand and 0.9 tons of gravel, gives a typical 3,000 psi mix. Measure by the bucket, not the shovel, and keep the water consistent between batches.

When bags are the right answer

  • Fence posts, sign posts and mailbox posts, one hole at a time.
  • Small repairs, steps and curbs.
  • Places a truck can't reach and a pump can't justify.
  • Jobs spread over several days where a single big pour isn't possible.

Use the slab calculator with Supply as set to each option to compare quantities on your own job, and the fence post concrete calculator for post holes.

Questions to ask the ready-mix plant

  • What's the minimum load, and what's the short-load fee below it?
  • How long is the free unloading time, and what do they charge per minute after it?
  • Can the truck reach the pour, and how far will the chute go? Do they offer a line pump or a conveyor?
  • What mix do they recommend for the job, and is it available at short notice?
  • Do they charge extra for Saturdays, early starts or hot-weather or cold-weather additives?

Getting the pour day right

Whichever way you go, the pour itself goes better with a plan. Have the forms checked, the reinforcement on chairs and the base damp (not wet) before the concrete arrives. Have enough hands: at least three people for a truck pour of a few yards, one discharging, one spreading and one screeding. Keep a few bags on site as a backup in case the estimate comes up a little short. A wheelbarrow of bagged mix can finish an edge without calling for another load.

For bag pours, set up a production line before you start: bags stacked next to the mixer, water measured into buckets, and a clear barrow route to the forms. Pour from the far end back toward the mixer, so you never have to cross fresh concrete.

This guide is general information for estimating. It is not engineering, legal or tax advice. Check local codes and your inspector for your project.

More guides